Validity of Apostolic Succession, and RCC as the One Holy Catholic Church

[Arch Stanton]

Here it is again for those who can't even scroll up:

When one can't seem to respond to #1, how can they get to #2?

One must crawl before they walk!

 

[Arial]

My response deals with the authority of Peter [keys of authority]... why would Luther say the representative?

Your response wasn't dealing with your own claim that I gave a rebuttal to. The conversation was not about the authority of Peter---that is a whole other set of posts you have failed to respond to--it was about you trying to say that Luther was supporting the papacy by yanking a quote of his out of his context. What I did was put it in its context to show what you had done.

Is all this obfuscating real confusion and inability to track even your own conversations real or is it a well-known Catholic tactic to try and make things so tangled and muddied for their own purpose? Which by the way only serves to show either the dogma is so intrenched the brain can no longer process thinking properly, or they have stopped up their ears against anything that the traditions of men of the RCC tell them will send them to hell. You are your own worst enemy in a debate.

 

[Arch Stanton]

Your response wasn't dealing with your own claim that I gave a rebuttal to. The conversation was not about the authority of Peter---that is a whole other set of posts you have failed to respond to--it was about you trying to say that Luther was supporting the papacy by yanking a quote of his out of his context. What I did was put it in its context to show what you had done.

Is all this obfuscating real confusion and inability to track even your own conversations real or is it a well-known Catholic tactic to try and make things so tangled and muddied for their own purpose? Which by the way only serves to show either the dogma is so intrenched the brain can no longer process thinking properly, or they have stopped up their ears against anything that the traditions of men of the RCC tell them will send them to hell. You are your own worst enemy in a debate.

Wasn't it you who changed things to 'rock' when that wasn't on the table? I'll go back and double check...

 

[Arial]

Wasn't it you who changed things to 'rock' when that wasn't on the table? I'll go back and double check...

You do that. I will be waiting.

 

[Arch Stanton]

You do that. I will be waiting.

post 96