• **Notifications**: Notifications can be dismissed by clicking on the "x" on the righthand side of the notice.
  • **New Style**: You can now change style options. Click on the paintbrush at the bottom of this page.
  • **Donations**: If the Lord leads you please consider helping with monthly costs and up keep on our Forum. Click on the Donate link In the top menu bar. Thanks
  • **New Blog section**: There is now a blog section. Check it out near the Private Debates forum or click on the Blog link in the top menu bar.
  • Welcome Visitors! Join us and be blessed while fellowshipping and celebrating our Glorious Salvation In Christ Jesus.

That stifling horror of smoky dark thickness

makesends

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
May 21, 2023
Messages
4,878
Reaction score
5,506
Points
138
Faith
Monergist
Country
USA
Marital status
Widower
Politics
Conservative
In my mind, at least, this site is dedicated to discussion and debate of substantive matters, particularly of God. This forum in particular is intended for that purpose. And I do not like to speculate in such a place, but all doctrinal truth —even the most well defined by us— induces within us incomplete thoughts, speculations, intuitions. Hopefully if admitted that it is speculation can keep us from much error.

But it seems to me that there is something missing from our notions modern day, of God's character that was assumed in earlier times, as being, not in antithesis to his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image, but in antithesis to what WE consider to be his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image.

The Simplicity of God teaches us that none of what we consider his attributes is without the others. They are not parts of him. Thus we need to understand that the power, burning purity and retribution against sin is entirely in keeping with his intent and actions towards those he made in his own image, and in keeping with his love, compassion and tender care, and vice versa.

One part of our humanity that is not of itself sinful, is the necessary self-determination (No, I did not say 'self-determinism') of the individual, to, as it is said, pursue happiness, self-preservation and other important things such as service and love for God and others. But that necessary part of us, perverted by the sin nature, reduces in one's mind the power, aseity (or self-ness), sovereignty and pertinence of God within and over all fact, because of the perceived importance of our own wonderful concepts.

The following, which seems almost entirely removed from our modern lexicon, is what I wish to discuss here: In the past, there was a general attitude toward life that admitted to the comprehension of the God of such things as the Angel of Death, and what CS Lewis described somewhere as, (as I remember it), a smoky, dark, stifling, viscous, engulfing, inescapable thickness of holiness. This is not just a lightning bolt and over with.

This discussion will of necessity involve speculation. I have heard little teaching on the matter. But my intuition tells me that it has a emanant truth to it—that there is something there, that, though in the hundreds of years past was a concept dealt with superstitiously, (just as it would be now, were we to consider it true), it should nevertheless be attributional toward the God to whom we show little fear.

What I would like to hear, is scripture passages with references that sound something like that. I would also enjoy reasoning that deals with this. To me, this too, speaks to God's superiority to all things, and that all fact descends from him, and is about him. I don't know if you will get that from it, but I would still like to hear responses to the question: Where do we see this, or read of this, in Scripture. And is it something he does, or something he is?

For example, does the horror of blood sacrifices touch on this?
 
Last edited:
Does this touch on how God uses the devil for his own purposes? Death for his own purposes? Does this touch on notions of hell and death? Or is it, rather, something about God himself?

Ah! I found it! —Or something very like it. From Til We Have Faces,
“Holy places are dark places. It is life and strength, not knowledge and words, that we get in them. Holy wisdom is not clear and thin like water, but thick and dark like blood.”
― C.S. Lewis, Till We Have Faces

Maybe the same God we should fear, is to the reprobate death, but life and strength to those who are in Him. It is no light undertaking to pursue this God, but it is death to fail to pursue him.
 
Last edited:
In my mind, at least, this site is dedicated to discussion and debate of substantive matters, particularly of God. This forum in particular is intended for that purpose. And I do not like to speculate in such a place, but all doctrinal truth —even the most well defined by us— induces within us incomplete thoughts, speculations, intuitions. Hopefully if admitted that it is speculation can keep us from much error.

But it seems to me that there is something missing from our notions modern day, of God's character that was assumed in earlier times, as being, not in antithesis to his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image, but in antithesis to what WE consider to be his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image.

The Simplicity of God teaches us that none of what we consider his attributes is without the others. They are not parts of him. Thus we need to understand that the power, burning purity and retribution against sin is entirely in keeping with his intent and actions towards those he made in his own image, and in keeping with his love, compassion and tender care, and vice versa.

One part of our humanity that is not of itself sinful, is the necessary self-determination (No, I did not say 'self-determinism') of the individual, to, as it is said, pursue happiness, self-preservation and other important things such as service and love for God and others. But that necessary part of us, perverted by the sin nature, reduces in one's mind the power, aseity (or self-ness), sovereignty and pertinence of God within and over all fact, because of the perceived importance of our own wonderful concepts.

The following, which seems almost entirely removed from our modern lexicon, is what I wish to discuss here: In the past, there was a general attitude toward life that admitted to the comprehension of the God of such things as the Angel of Death, and what CS Lewis described somewhere as, (as I remember it), a smoky, dark, stifling, viscous, engulfing, inescapable thickness of holiness. This is not just a lightning bolt and over with.

This discussion will of necessity involve speculation. I have heard little teaching on the matter. But my intuition tells me that it has a emanant truth to it—that there is something there, that, though in the hundreds of years past was a concept dealt with superstitiously, (just as it would be now, were we to consider it true), it should nevertheless be attributional toward the God to whom we show little fear.

What I would like to hear, is scripture passages with references that sound something like that. I would also enjoy reasoning that deals with this. To me, this too, speaks to God's superiority to all things, and that all fact descends from him, and is about him. I don't know if you will get that from it, but I would still like to hear responses to the question: Where do we see this, or read of this, in Scripture. And is it something he does, or something he is?

For example, does the horror of blood sacrifices touch on this?
I think Job chapters 38-41, where God speaks to Job applies to what you are asking for. And I think Job "saw" it.

The reason I say that is, given all the things that Job's friends had said to him about God, that were true, just misapplied; and given all the knowledge of God that Job himself expressed; it is odd that after God stops speaking to Job, Job replies in 42:5 I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you."

Interestinly, and in connection to Lewis' words, God spoke to Job out of the whirlwind.
 
Last edited:
In my mind, at least, this site is dedicated to discussion and debate of substantive matters, particularly of God. This forum in particular is intended for that purpose. And I do not like to speculate in such a place, but all doctrinal truth —even the most well defined by us— induces within us incomplete thoughts, speculations, intuitions. Hopefully if admitted that it is speculation can keep us from much error.

But it seems to me that there is something missing from our notions modern day, of God's character that was assumed in earlier times, as being, not in antithesis to his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image, but in antithesis to what WE consider to be his love, compassion, tender care and positive intent toward those he made in his own image.

The Simplicity of God teaches us that none of what we consider his attributes is without the others. They are not parts of him. Thus we need to understand that the power, burning purity and retribution against sin is entirely in keeping with his intent and actions towards those he made in his own image, and in keeping with his love, compassion and tender care, and vice versa.

One part of our humanity that is not of itself sinful, is the necessary self-determination (No, I did not say 'self-determinism') of the individual, to, as it is said, pursue happiness, self-preservation and other important things such as service and love for God and others. But that necessary part of us, perverted by the sin nature, reduces in one's mind the power, aseity (or self-ness), sovereignty and pertinence of God within and over all fact, because of the perceived importance of our own wonderful concepts.

The following, which seems almost entirely removed from our modern lexicon, is what I wish to discuss here: In the past, there was a general attitude toward life that admitted to the comprehension of the God of such things as the Angel of Death, and what CS Lewis described somewhere as, (as I remember it), a smoky, dark, stifling, viscous, engulfing, inescapable thickness of holiness. This is not just a lightning bolt and over with.

This discussion will of necessity involve speculation. I have heard little teaching on the matter. But my intuition tells me that it has a emanant truth to it—that there is something there, that, though in the hundreds of years past was a concept dealt with superstitiously, (just as it would be now, were we to consider it true), it should nevertheless be attributional toward the God to whom we show little fear.

What I would like to hear, is scripture passages with references that sound something like that. I would also enjoy reasoning that deals with this. To me, this too, speaks to God's superiority to all things, and that all fact descends from him, and is about him. I don't know if you will get that from it, but I would still like to hear responses to the question: Where do we see this, or read of this, in Scripture. And is it something he does, or something he is?

For example, does the horror of blood sacrifices touch on this?
There's someone over on CF by the name of Colo Millz that you might like corresponding with.
 
There's someone over on CF by the name of Colo Millz that you might like corresponding with.
I'll look him up. Thanks.
 
Back
Top