Purpose of This Forum

[John Bauer]

Purpose of This Forum​

This forum exists to provide a focused environment for explaining, examining, and defending the history, doctrines, and theological claims of the Roman Catholic church. It is intended as a place where Roman Catholics may clarify and defend the teachings of their communion, and where non-Catholics may question, challenge, or critically evaluate those teachings. All discussions remain subject to the CCAM Rules & Guidelines, which govern tone, conduct, and argumentative standards across the site.

The purpose of this forum is

• to allow Roman Catholics to explain and defend Catholic doctrine.
  
  ​
• to allow non-Catholics to inquire, challenge, argue, or critique Catholic claims.
  
  ​
• to provide a structured environment where Catholic theology can be described accurately and tested rigorously.
  
  ​
• to permit discussion of any Catholic doctrine, from ecclesiology to sacramental theology, within a Christ-centered setting.

Participants may debate any Catholic doctrine, practice, or historical claim—including Marian dogmas, papal primacy, sacramental theology, and magisterial authority—provided they do so in accordance with the CCAM rules governing civility, accuracy, and engagement with rebuttals.

What Will Not Be Tolerated​

This forum is not a proselytizing platform. The following behaviors are not permitted here:

• Active recruitment, whether explicit or implicit (e.g., “You should join the Roman Catholic Church; message me privately if you want guidance”).
  
  ​
• Conversion-directed appeals framed as calls to join Rome or to submit to papal authority.
  
  ​
• Attempts to use private messages to recruit, persuade, or pressure individuals toward Rome or any other communion.
  
  ​
• Attempts to pressure participants to leave their communion for institutional, sacramental, or ecclesiastical reasons.
  
  ​
• Coercive or manipulative pressure to accept doctrinal claims beyond normal argumentative exchange.

Nuanced Clarification for This Forum​

The CCAM staff holds that spiritual allegiance belongs to Christ himself alone, not to any human bishop or ecclesiastical institution, and therefore we do not oppose calling anyone, Catholic or otherwise, to personal allegiance to Christ. This conviction does not authorize pressuring individuals into leaving their communion for institutional or denominational reasons, nor does it permit recruitment into another communion. All appeals to follow Christ or to adhere to the apostolic gospel of Christ must remain free of sectarian aims, denominational pressure, or manipulative rhetoric.

Scope of Permitted Debate​

• Respectful challenges to Catholic doctrines are fully allowed.
  
  ​
• Non-Catholics may start critical or analytical threads (e.g., “Why Catholic Marian dogmas are unbiblical.”)
  
  ​
• Catholics may respond by explaining or defending their position.
  
  ​
• All parties must abide by CCAM standards for civility, accuracy, engagement, and representation.

Relation to the CCAM Rules​

All CCAM Rules & Guidelines apply with full force within this forum. This sticky post introduces forum-specific expectations related to proselytizing or ecclesial recruitment, which function as binding supplements to the general rules.