• **Notifications**: Notifications can be dismissed by clicking on the "x" on the righthand side of the notice.
  • **New Style**: You can now change style options. Click on the paintbrush at the bottom of this page.
  • **Donations**: If the Lord leads you please consider helping with monthly costs and up keep on our Forum. Click on the Donate link In the top menu bar. Thanks
  • **New Blog section**: There is now a blog section. Check it out near the Private Debates forum or click on the Blog link in the top menu bar.
  • Welcome Visitors! Join us and be blessed while fellowshipping and celebrating our Glorious Salvation In Christ Jesus.

Are there modern day prophets and Apostle then today?

Those holding to modern day prophets and Apostle do not subscribe to a completed canon was already completed, as they still claim to be getting revelations from God for today per them, mainly they are rehashing the heresy of latter day rain manifest sons of God theology
I would like to see the evidence for that assertion.

I think R. C. Sproul's distinction between revelation and illumination is correct and astute. God has revealed His revelation in His written word, but He continues to illuminate its depths, often bringing knew understanding. Nothing newly understood can, however contradict what is clearly stated.
 
I would like to see the evidence for that assertion.

I think R. C. Sproul's distinction between revelation and illumination is correct and astute. God has revealed His revelation in His written word, but He continues to illuminate its depths, often bringing knew understanding. Nothing newly understood can, however contradict what is clearly stated.
Word of Faith teachers who claim prophetic mantle are giving new and false so called revelation on a regular basis
 
Word of Faith teachers who claim prophetic mantle are giving new and false so called revelation on a regular basis
What does that have to do with modern-day prophets and apostles. Have we not already established WoF self-proclaimed "prophets" and "apostles" are neither? What then about non-WoFs?
 
What does that have to do with modern-day prophets and apostles. Have we not already established WoF self-proclaimed "prophets" and "apostles" are neither? What then about non-WoFs?
Only they are claiming to be prophets and Apostles for today
 
Oops, sorry.
No worries. Just want to stay focused with @JesusFan
Really? Can I ask why not? I'm curious.
Sure, but you'll have to start a new thread because I won't take this one far afield of the op and a discussion pertaining to whether and why we are or aren't in the last days will take us that direction. I will say this......

When Peter was preaching under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost he quoted the prophet Joel, saying,

Acts 2:17-18
But this is what was uttered through the prophet Joel: “‘And in the last days it shall be, God declares, that I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams; even on my male servants and female servants in those days I will pour out my Spirit, and they shall prophesy.

  1. Men and women will prophecy in the last days.
  2. We are, according to Post #66, living in the last days 😉.
  3. Therefore, there are modern-day prophets.

😮

Of course, if we're not in the last days then there would be a basis for saying there are no modern-day prophets 🤨. Surprised this wasn't already posted by someone else. Looking forward to reading @JesusFan's response 😁.

You post the op, mention me in it so I know it's up, and I'll post a viewpoint.




.
 
No worries. Just want to stay focused with @JesusFan

Sure, but you'll have to start a new thread because I won't take this one far afield of the op and a discussion pertaining to whether and why we are or aren't in the last days will take us that direction. I will say this......

When Peter was preaching under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost he quoted the prophet Joel, saying,

Acts 2:17-18
But this is what was uttered through the prophet Joel: “‘And in the last days it shall be, God declares, that I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams; even on my male servants and female servants in those days I will pour out my Spirit, and they shall prophesy.

  1. Men and women will prophecy in the last days.
  2. We are, according to Post #66, living in the last days 😉.
  3. Therefore, there are modern-day prophets.

😮

Of course, if we're not in the last days then there would be a basis for saying there are no modern-day prophets 🤨. Surprised this wasn't already posted by someone else. Looking forward to reading @JesusFan's response 😁.

You post the op, mention me in it so I know it's up, and I'll post a viewpoint.




.
Might be those who have the gift tp prophesy, that though is NOT occupying officeo f a prophet
 
No worries. Just want to stay focused with @JesusFan

Sure, but you'll have to start a new thread because I won't take this one far afield of the op and a discussion pertaining to whether and why we are or aren't in the last days will take us that direction. I will say this......

When Peter was preaching under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost he quoted the prophet Joel, saying,

Acts 2:17-18
But this is what was uttered through the prophet Joel: “‘And in the last days it shall be, God declares, that I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams; even on my male servants and female servants in those days I will pour out my Spirit, and they shall prophesy.

  1. Men and women will prophecy in the last days.
  2. We are, according to Post #66, living in the last days 😉.
  3. Therefore, there are modern-day prophets.

😮

Of course, if we're not in the last days then there would be a basis for saying there are no modern-day prophets 🤨. Surprised this wasn't already posted by someone else. Looking forward to reading @JesusFan's response 😁.

You post the op, mention me in it so I know it's up, and I'll post a viewpoint.




.
Haha!! Great logic, there!
 
Have been since Jesus ascension, but also do hold to the Great persecution in end of the last days, leading up to the Second Coming event
See Post #69 😏.

  1. Joel and Peter stated men and women would prophesy in the last days.
  2. According to Post 70, we have in the last days since Jesus' ascension.
  3. There are, therefore, modern-day prophets today.

Your response?
Might be those who have the gift tp prophesy, that though is NOT occupying office of a prophet
At the risk of recycling old content, what is the difference? How can someone prophecy and not be a prophet? How can prophecies be promised in the ast day and people not prophecy if we are still living in the last days?

Where does scripture mention something called an "office" of prophet? I mentioned the word "office" simply as a designator of role or position of leadership - one of meany that was neither permanent nor occupationally static or fixed - not as something separating some people from all others in the body of Christ. It's odd that you would assert the premise of an "office" in some other way because that is what the WoF does. Can you use the WoF definition and decry the WoF practice while asserting an alternative using the WoF definition? That would be circular reasoning.


If we are living in the last days, then there are prophets today. According to Matthew 24 and 25, Jesus stated one of the signs of the end of the age would be the existence of false prophets. If there are no modern-day prophets today, then even though the last days still exist it would/will be very easy to observe any false prophet because anyone and everyone who prophesies or claims to prophesy is false!

How is the conundrum reconciled?
 
No worries. Just want to stay focused with @JesusFan

Sure, but you'll have to start a new thread because I won't take this one far afield of the op and a discussion pertaining to whether and why we are or aren't in the last days will take us that direction.
Fair enough. Thanks
 
Would he be them holding to pretierist theology?
Every Christian is partial-preterist.

Including you, @JesusFan.

The word "praeter" from which "preterism" is derived simply means "past." That's it. Nothing more. Every Christian is partially preterist because s/he believes Jesus is the Messiah. Jesus is the promised anointed one of God and there will be no other Messiah. He is it. That means every single Christian believes all the Old Testament prophecies promising a Messiah would come are fulfilled are fulfilled in the past by Jesus. Christians are Christological preterists. Every single one of us.

Including you, @JesusFan.

To deny the OT messianic prophecies are fulfilled by Jesus is to not be a Christian.

Next, to the degree that Jesus was foretold to come in the last days, those promises are all also eschatological.

Hebrews 9:24-26
24
For Christ did not enter a holy place made by hands, a mere copy of the true one, but into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God for us; 25nor was it that he would offer himself often, as the high priest enters the Holy Place year by year with blood that is not his own. 26Otherwise, he would have needed to suffer often since the foundation of the world; but now once at the consummation of the ages he has been revealed to put away sin by the sacrifice of Himself.

1 Peter 1:17-21
17
If you address as Father the One who impartially judges according to each one’s work, conduct yourselves in fear during the time of your stay on earth; 18knowing that you were not redeemed with perishable things like silver or gold from your futile way of life inherited from your forefathers, 19but with precious blood, as of a lamb unblemished and spotless, the blood of Christ. 20For He was foreknown before the foundation of the world but has appeared in these last times for the sake of you 21who through Him are believers in God, who raised Him from the dead and gave Him glory, so that your faith and hope are in God.

Jesus was revealed at the end of the ages. Jesus appeared in the last times.

If this is denied, then a person is not a Christian.

Therefore, every Christian is both a Christological preterist and an eschatological partial preterist. The only question is to what degree is a Christian partial? Even many Dispensationalist Premillennialists are partial preterists. Leaky Dispensationalist John MacArthur, for example, taught the first three chapters of Revelation pertain to the first century. Fully-committed Dispensationalist Gary Hamrick also teaches that interpretation. That makes both men partial preterist.

The problem with them is that they and all the other Dispensational Premillennialist teach falsehoods about preterism. When they teach about preterism they teach preterists believe ALL the prophecies in the Bible are fulfilled. That is a lie from the pit of hell. Most prets are partial prets. I'd venture to say less than 10% of all preterists are fully preterist. Theirs is a minority view, a statistical and normative outlier. Whereas every Christian is partially preterist simply because they believe Jesus fulfills the messianic prophecies and he came in the last days, the full preterists goes well beyond orthodoxy to say all prophecy has been fulfilled and Jesus has come all he is going to come and he will not be coming again.

As far as I know no one in CCAM denies the so-called "Second Coming." Me included.

Sadly, what the Dispensationalists teach about preterism has adversely influenced many Christians, including Historic Premillennialists.

The second big lie about preterism is that preterism is a method. Preterism is not a method of interpretation. Preterism is a conclusion of exegetical interpretation. We do not read fulfillment into verses like Revelation 1:3. We read Revelation 1:3 exactly as written with the normal meaning of the words in their ordinary usage and accept it and believe the verse exactly as written. We do not add to nor subtract from the verse. We then apply what that verse plainly states to other relevant content. We do NOT go around eisegetically applying that verse to every other verse in the Bible because of some pre-existing eschatology.
Would he be them holding to pretierist theology?
There is no such thing as "preterist theology." I am partially preterist. So are you. You may not realize it but f you found yourself agreeing with anything I posted above in this post then the only question is to what degree are you partially preterist.

Now please stop hopping around from subject to subject, never directly answering anyone's questions in a timely manner and please respond to the case presented in Post #69 and Post 74. This op is about the existence of modern-day prophets (and apostles) today. You have stated the last days have been in existence since Jesus ascended. Scripture says otherwise but I am working with what you have provided. The last days began when Jesus ascended. Joel and Peter report people will prophecy in the last days. Therefore, since we are - according to you and @Carbon - living in the last days, there must be modern-day prophets living today.

  1. Joel and Peter stated men and women would prophesy in the last days.
  2. According to Post 70, we have in the last days since Jesus' ascension.
  3. There are, therefore, modern-day prophets today.

Your response?

Work it out for me. Work it out with me, if you like. How are we to reconcile the belief we're living in the last days with the promise of God people will prophesy in the last day? How do you reconcile your belief we're living in the last day when there will be people prophesying with the belief the only prophets that exist today are WoF false prophets?

Those wishing to chime in, please give @JesusFan an opportunity to answer for himself unobstructed. tia
I can't answer for @Josheb, nor will I attempt to, but I do not believe he is a preterist.
I am preterist. I am, like all Christians, partial preterist, and like most partial preterists eagerly looking forward to the return of Christ when the old heavens and earth pass away and the new city of peace descends from heaven after the thousand years of Revelation 20 and the fiery lake day of sentencing. You do the same..... just differently ;).

None of which has anything to do with this op or the question(s) I have put to @JesusFan.




Aside from the heretical nonsense taught by the WoF, if God promised people would prophesy in the last days and we are living in the last days, then how can the existence of modern-day prophets living today be denied?

Hint: you were sorta on the right track when discriminating between the "office" and the act, @JesusFan. Follow that rationale through using the whole of scripture.






.
 
according to you and @Carbon - living in the last days, there must be modern-day prophets living today.
Pardon me, but thats nonsense. Because I believe we are living in the last days, it does not mean there are modern-day prophets. I believe you are wrong here. The last days started at Jesus' first coming. And we are still in them.
I am preterist. I am, like all Christians, partial preterist,
A preterist and a partial preterist are quite different, you do realize that?
 
Pardon me, but thats nonsense. Because I believe we are living in the last days, it does not mean there are modern-day prophets.
Acts 2 says there will be people prophesying in the last days. Scripture is notnonsense.
I believe you are wrong here. The last days started at Jesus' first coming. And we are still in them.
Peter (and Joel) stated there would be people prophesying in the last days. The conflict is not with scripture. The conflict exists within the position the last days exist, but prophets do not. How do you reconcile those two positions that you hold?

In other words, my observation has absolutely nothing to do with me or what I believe. I have simply cited a pair of verses stating people will prophecy in the last days and ask you and @JesusFan to explain how there could be no prophets if we are living in the last days (there is an explanatory answer, but neither one of you have provided it).
A preterist and a partial preterist are quite different, you do realize that?
Ah. The post was either not completely read or not read with much thought, was it?


[Full] preterists believe ALL the prophecies in the Bible are fulfilled. That is a lie from the pit of hell. Most preterists are partial preterist. I'd venture to say less than 10% of all preterists are fully preterist. Theirs (the full preterists') is a minority view, a statistical and normative outlier. Whereas every Christian is partially preterist simply because they believe Jesus fulfills the messianic prophecies and he came in the last days, the full preterist goes well beyond orthodoxy to say all prophecy has been fulfilled and Jesus has come all he is going to come, and he will not be coming again.



Yes, I do know there is a difference. I explicitly stated as much in Post #78. A full preterist believes all prophecies of the Bible have been fulfilled and a partial preterist does not. The word "preterist" does not inherently mean "full-preterist." Those who conflate the two are making a mistake. Not all preterists are full preterist. Most preterists are not full preterist.


Now how about one of you get back on the topic of this op and explain how we can be living in the last days without any prophets when scripture states there will be people prophesying in the last days (there is an explanatory answer, but neither one of you have provided it).


"And in the last days it shall be,
God declares,
that I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh,

AND YOUR SONS AND YOUR DAUGHTERS SHALL PROPHECY,
and your young men shall see visions,
and your old men shall dream dreams
..."

(Acts 2:17)


in the last days........................ your sons and daughters shall prophecy


Scripture doesn't merely point to truth—it is the truth. Is that something you actually believe or is that placation? People will prophesy in the last days and you both state we are in the last days. Why does this have to be asked so multiple times before an answer is forthcoming? The question has absolutely nothing to do with preterism (post 72 is a red herring). The question is a valid and op-relevant inquiry based on comments posted in the thread.


How can it be said there are no prophets today when Acts 2:17 explicitly states there will be people prophesying in the last days and you two say we are in the last days?

See Post #69 😏.

  1. Joel and Peter stated men and women would prophesy in the last days.
  2. According to Post 70, we have in the last days since Jesus' ascension.
  3. There are, therefore, modern-day prophets today.

How is this seeming discrepancy to be reconciled (there is an explanatory answer, but neither one of you have provided it)?

How can it be said there are no prophets today when Acts 2:17 explicitly states there will be people prophesying in the last days and you two say we are in the last days?
 
How can it be said there are no prophets today when Acts 2:17 explicitly states there will be people prophesying in the last days and you two say we are in the last days?
If prophecy continues and is infallible it competes with Scripture. If it is fallible, it redefines prophecy itself.

So, if the last days are "this age", the time period between the first and second coming of Christ, what does Acts 2:17 mean?

Since this prophecy of Joel is tied to Pentecost and the Spirit being poured out, it could refer to, not revelatory prophecy, but the preaching and teaching of the word as revealed in the apostles laying of the foundation of the church and extended--to Spirit filled believers preaching and teaching that word of God. Spreading the gospel, giving understanding of the word of God. Staying always on that foundation and not adding to it or taking away from it.

The problem with those in the modern church who claim the office of prophet and also claim they are not adding to the word---they have stepped off the foundation and mostly don't even know it. Acts 2:17 does not say the office of prophet as we see in the OT will continue. It ceased with the apostolic age and the death of the apostles.
 
Back
Top